Subscribe

Making an Appeal in Massachusetts

Update: In recent news, Avery’s attorneys have submitted a number of appeals documents.  Several of these have been denied, however it appears one or more of these are still winding their ways up through the Appeals Courts.  Brandan Dassey, however, may have exhausted all of his appeals.  He has appealed to the current Governor for clemency but that was also refused.  There are still talks about Making a Murderer Part 3, which is rumored to name who many believe to be the “real killer”.  We will keep you updated as more news becomes available.
If you have Netflix, Facebook or even see the news, you have probably heard about the show “Making a Murderer”.  It is a Netflix documentary about the conviction of two men, Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey, from Wisconsin, who were convicted for the murder of Teresa Halbach.  It has become a highly publicized case for many reasons but it started because of the documentary.  While the documentary was probably created with entertainment in mind, it’s become significant to the legal community for several reasons.  First, there is the question of whether one or both of the defendants were wrongfully convicted.  Second, there are issues relating to possible misconduct by the State’s office during the murder investigation.  For appellate reasons, there are questions about the  evidence, which is the focus of our article, Making an Appeal in Massachusetts.  We are going to take a look at how the appeal of Steven Avery may have played out if his conviction had taken place in Massachusetts.

The Back Story

In order to fully understand this situation, you must know some of the details of Avery’s story.  Steven Avery was previously convicted for the rape of a woman and spent a number of years in prison, always claiming his innocence in the crime.  After serving 18 years of his 20 year sentence, evidence came to light that another person really did commit that crime and Avery was exonerated by DNA.  Having just been set free, he filed suit for $36 million against the Manitowoc County for the injustice.  It should be noted that he filed suit largely because it became known that authorities had knowledge of the actual perpetrator years before Avery was set free, yet took no action to investigate.
Depositions took place on October 11-13, 2005 in the lawsuit to determine whether Manitowoc officials should be named as co-defendants in the lawsuit.  Teresa Halbach was reported missing on November 3rd,  2005 by her parents.  The Avery Auto Salvage Yard was the last place she was scheduled as an Auto Trader photographer.
Police arrested Avery who maintained his innocence.  A few months later they arrested his nephew, Brendan Dassey.  Dassey was underage with a low IQ and mental capacity.  Furthermore, he was questioned without a legal guardian present.  By watching the police interrogations, it appears he grasped a general lack of understanding of the legal consequences of his responses.   Brendan Dassey’s questioning is exactly the type of interrogation that warrants legal guardians to be present during questioning.
Both men were convicted.  There were a number of questionable issues regarding evidence during the trial.  Those were brought up and “preserved” for the record to be used in upcoming appeals.

Breaking it Down

Judge (Process)

As we have discussed previously in All About Appeals, an appeal can only be brought to litigate very specific circumstances such as wrong doing during the original trial, newly found evidence,  or a violation of the defendant’s constitutional rights.  Avery and Dassey both had a multitude of appeals.  There were also civil suits brought on by the Halbach family against Avery after his conviction.  The Appellate Court judge presided over the civil case against Avery.   In Massachusetts, the Appeal’s Court sits separate and apart from the lower courts in order for the panel to be completely disinterested.  This idea is for the Appeal’s Court to take a new look at the case and to review the lower Court’s finding.  Judges who sit on this Court do not sit also in the lower court.  Judges on the Appeal’s Court do, however, have history and may have sat in a particular lower Court.  There is currently one chief and 23 associates justices on the panel. For direct  appeals, the Judges sit in sets of three to hear argument.  If there is a connection to a case that renders a particular Judge in conflict, the case would be reassigned to a different panel of Judges.     If the Avery matter were pending in Massachusetts, its highly likely that the case would be reassigned to a different panel to ensure that there was no conflict or bias and that the appeal was determined solely on the facts.  Avery’s current attorney is asking that the Judge recuse herself in light of the fact that she previously sat on a lower court decision.  In Massachusetts, and many other states, there is a process already in place to protect the defendant and this motion would not necessarily need to be made.  It is a process of the system to protect the rights of the appellee.

The Bones (Evidence)

A key piece of evidence that was used against Avery during the trial was the supposed presence of Teresa’s remains in a burn barrel on the Avery property .  Appellate lawyer, Kathleen Zellner, asked for the remains to be released so that new technology can be used to to test DNA from the bones.  The bones were a key component of the State’s case for the conviction of Avery.  This DNA testing is a type of testing that did not exist at the time of the first trial and therefore may have never been done.  This amounts of evidence that did not exist at the time of trial.  However, upon the request, Avery learned that that the bones were allegedly given back to the Halbach family, a direct violation of law in the Wisconsin case.  How would this play out in Massachusetts?
In a case I argued on appeal, the defense went to trial without a very important piece of evidence.  I argued that the Commonwealth’s failure to disclose the evidence was prejudicial to the defendant.  In my case, the defendant was charged with assault and battery on a police officer.  The allegation was that he struck an officer in the booking area of the police station.  The station had a camera in that area which produces a video.  The defense had requested a copy of the video recording from the booking room at the police station.  The recording was essential because it was the best evidence to potentially show guilt or innocence of my client.  However, when trial counsel  requested that evidence, he learned that the video feed ran on a system that erased the data after a certain period of time and at the point it was requested by the defendant, it had been destroyed.   At trial, defense counsel raised the issue in his closing argument.  The Commonwealth argued that the jurors need not speculate why there was no video.  The trial Judge refused to instruct the jury on this issue.
On appeal, I argued first, that it was the Commonwealth’s duty to disclose this evidence, as it was in their possession, and there was no duty on behalf of the defendant to take further steps to preserve that evidence; Second, that the Commonwealth was ordered to produce the video but failed to do so; Third, that the destruction of the video was prejudicial to my client.  it was a violation of my client’s rights.  He was entitled to have all evidence to his defense; Finally, that lack of a jury instruction addressing this issue was prejudicial to the defendant.   The Court ruled that the trial judge erred in determining that the Commonwealth had no culpability, given that the police department had a video recording of an alleged crime committed in its booking area with which the defendant was charged and thus required no further notification by the defendant to recognize the need to preserve the evidence, and also erroneously failed to consider and then weigh the Commonwealth’s negligence.  The Court further rules that the video was material (as found by the trial judge) prejudice to the defendant arose from the combination of the Commonwealth’s failure to preserve and produce the video, the judge’s declining to instruct the jury on how to consider the evidence, and the prosecutor’s argument to the jury that they should not speculate why there was no video.
You can read more about that case here:  http://masscases.com/cases/app/89/89massappct328.html

In Summary

In the Avery case, if there is evidence that can exonerate a person, it is essential to the case.  Evidence cannot be destroyed or disposed of during the pendency of the case (including appeals).  Anything may be called into question at a later date and it is reasonable to believe that a person’s body may be needed to test for DNA as scientific testing advances.  In this situation, all appeals had not yet been exhausted.
If you have been convicted of a crime in Massachusetts and need a skilled litigator with appellate experience, call us.  Christine can speak to you in a free phone consultation to be sure you are hiring the right person.  Calling us costs you nothing.  Doing nothing could cost you everything. Contact us here for a consultation.

Custody: Can My Child Decide?

Very often I am asked “when can my child decide choose where he lives?” or “at what age will the Court listen to my children’s input?” The short answer to this question is that there is no “magic age” to answer "can my child decided" which the court will let the child...

Who Gets the Engagement Ring?

The contemplation of marriage, instituted by the engagement of the parties, traditionally brings with it an engagement ring given from one to another.  Some have sentimental value:  engagement rings are handed down and are often heirlooms.  An engagement ring may have...

My best divorce advice: Don’t listen to your family & friends!

Sounds silly, right? It’s the best divorce advice that any attorney can give is don't listen to your family & friends. Your family and friends always want what’s best for you. They are there to love and support you. You look to them for help and guidance. When you...

When to seek counseling for your child?

Divorce and separation issues are very hard on children.  Whether parents are starting the divorce, discussing the break up or have already gone their individual ways, children are often assumed to be in the dark about the whole situation.  Nothing could be further...

Topics You Should Discuss With Your Divorce Lawyer

Hiring a divorce lawyer is the first important step in a long list of your divorce. Once you retain a lawyer it is vitally important that you communicate openly and honestly with her.  She is there to to advocate for you to get the best solution for your situation. We...

Estate Planning After Divorce

Estate Planning After Divorce After a divorce, the last thing that anyone wants to think about is seeing an attorney, legal matters, planning the future, that sort of thing. The sad truth is that this is probably the most important time to get your estate plan revised...

What Happens to the Family Home in a Divorce?

A large concern during divorce consultation is the marital home. What will happen? Can I stay? Will I be forced out? Can I afford it? How will the Court decide to which party the home is awarded? The answers to these questions will often determine the outcome of other...

Free Consultation: Is it Worth It?

We often read other articles and posts and we came across a series of discussions recently debating whether or not there was a benefit to contacting an attorney for a free consultation.  While not all lawyers offer this service, our office does offer this service.  We...

Family Law: How to Choose Your Attorney

Your family is the most important thing in your life.  Whether you are facing a divorce or a custody battle or a child support dispute, you want to have the “right” attorney by your side through this very difficult process.  So, how do you decide?   Here are some...

Massachusetts Divorce: “What’s this going to cost me?”

   Whether you’re the husband or the wife, the bread winner or the stay-at-home parent, cost is typically a factor in consideration of a divorce. At some point during every consultation, a person turns to me and says “So, what’s this going to cost me?” My response is...

The Importance of an Appeal

Aaron Hernandez, famed football player who was convicted of murder and later, committed suicide has, once again, been in the news.  You may recall that before his death, his murder conviction was working its way through the stages of the Appeal's Court.  Aaron...

New Child Support Guidelines 2017 – Part 2

Welcome back to part 2 of our series on the new Child Support Guidelines (2017 version).  This section will address the increase to the minimum child support order.  If you missed our previous article, you can find it here, at:  New Guidelines Overview. Increase of...

Expectations after Divorce

           In a relationship, we have certain expectations of our spouse, our partner and perhaps the other parent to our children. Often, the other party will try to do what you’d like. But what happens when the relationship is no longer? Is it realistic to have the...

Modification: The In’s and Out’s

As life changes, you may find yourself in a situation where your current order (or judgment) no longer applies to your circumstances or seems fair, given your life changes. If you find yourself in this situation, speak with an attorney to determine if you would...

Five Tips for Attending Court

Often I am asked "what do I wear?" or "is there anything that I need to know about going to Court?" Below are tips for attending Court that I find rather useful. 1. Dress appropriately. It is not necessary to wear a suit or formal outfit to Court. Wear an outfit that...

I Want Her Out Now!

I want him/her out - now! When a married couple agrees to divorce, it signals the end of the union. However, it is easy to recognize that there are still many unanswered questions. I am often  asked this question by one of the parties: "We have already agreed the...

Cheating Spouse: How Do You Know?

Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie have been all over the news lately about their divorce.  There have been numerous reasons cited for the divorce.  Everything from drug abuse to physical abuse to affairs.   Both have been married AND divorced more than once.  In this and...

What is Sole Custody?

Often people come to me and want “sole custody” of their child.  What does this mean?  Is it often awarded?  Why? How can you convince the Court to award it to you?  Sole Legal Custody in MA:   In Massachusetts, the Court will award “legal” custody, which refers...

Questions You Should Ask Your Divorce Attorney

When seeking a divorce attorney, there are a million questions running through your mind.  It’s wise to make a list of the topics you wish to address so that you can make the most of your time together.  Here are some questions you should be sure make that list: 1. ...

Legal Lessons From a Mistress

The following is from someone who asked to share her story so others could learn from her Legal Lessons From a Mistress. Several years ago I went through a nasty divorce after 17 years of marriage.  At the end of it, I vowed never to allow myself to fall for another...

Visitation: Part 1: What happens if a parent never shows up for visitation?

     While you hate to give up time with your child, you know that the visitation with his other parent is good for their relationship, can be a very positive thing and (let’s face it) is a little break for you. Even if you don’t look forward to that time when your...

How to Build Financial Security When Facing Divorce

How to Build Financial Security When Facing Divorce If you see divorce or separation looming in your future, there are ways to plan ahead and build financial security to prepare for what could be a financially difficult time ahead.   Here are some tips for you to...

Prenuptial Agreements: Why Would I Want That?

It's hard to think that a divorce might happen when you are in the midst of planning your marriage and happily dreaming about the rest of your life, isn’t it?  How do you plan a happy life while deciding what to do if it all goes south?  The problem is that most...

West Memphis 3 – Reopening of Original Murder Case

UPDATE April 2020: Oxygen Network aired its long awaited show about this case.  It featured Bob Ruff's Truth & Justice working with famed former FBI profiler Jim Clemente and others to re-start an investigation in a manner they believe it should have been done...

2017 Child Support Guidelines – Overview

As most of you know, the new version of the child support guidelines has now been released and were effective beginning September 15, 2017.  Every four years, a task force reviews input and issue regarding the guidelines, making changes to accommodate problematic,...

Re-establishing Parenting Time

In August, I wrote about the Parent that Used to Be Absent.  This is a follow up article to that post about re-establishing parenting time and what to realistically expect when trying to do so. Often I speak with a parent that hasn’t seen their child in a long period...

Parental Alienation – Things to Watch

Over the recent month I have written about parental alienation in a couple of articles.  It is one of those painful situations for both the parents and the children and it's something that does not have to happen at all.  Often the process begins slowly and builds...

Annulment: Legal vs Religious

Annulment:  Legal versus Religious – an important distinction In the past  I wrote an article about annulment in each state:  Massachusetts and New Hampshire.  As I wrapped up the last article, I realized that I should discuss just one more point about annulment that...

Legal Meaning of the Cosby Mistrial

I’m sure you’ve all heard by now that Bill Cosby’s trial resulted in a mistrial on Saturday.   The jury came back to the judge, for the second time, on Saturday and informed him that they could not reach a verdict.  As a result, the Court declared a “mistrial.” So,...

For my Massachusetts Divorce, do I need my marriage certificate?

In Massachusetts, when you file a Complaint for Divorce, you must also file a certified copy of your marriage certificate. You may want to keep your copy or you may not have it. So, how do you get one? This is an easy issue to resolve. Contact the city hall in the...

Should You Date Before Your Divorce Is Final?

You filed a Complaint for Divorce and are ready to move on with your life. Should you date before your divorce is final?  Can dating someone hurt you while you are going through the divorce process? Could dating hurt you at all? Although it is always best to wait...

What To Do (and Not Do) If Your Spouse Is Cheating

It’s a difficult prospect to think that your spouse may have strayed from your marriage.  Most people find this shocking and upsetting, not knowing what to do (and what not to do)  if your spouse is cheating.  It's hard to decide at that moment about your marriage,...

Making an Appeal in Massachusetts

Update: In recent news, Avery's attorneys have submitted a number of appeals documents.  Several of these have been denied, however it appears one or more of these are still winding their ways up through the Appeals Courts.  Brandan Dassey, however, may have exhausted...

My ex won’t pay child support. Can I refuse to let him see the kids?

My  ex won’t pay child support. Can I refuse to let him see our daughter? Absolutely not! If you do it, you are in contempt. Child support and parenting time are two separate issues. If there is an order for support and an order for parenting time, each of the parties...

Wait! We Didn’t Mean to Divorce! Can’t We Get a Do-Over?

During the month of December, the New Hampshire Supreme Court upheld a lower Court’s decision that a couple cannot “un-divorce,” or “vacate” their divorce, by joint motion to the Court. In this particular case, a couple that had divorced after 24 years of marriage...

Who is Using Your DNA?

Who is using your DNA? If you have watched any television recently, you may have noticed an increase in the DNA profile commercials.  You know the ones – “I thought I was from Italy, but turns out I am mostly Scottish” and they promote that you can also learn your...

Massachusetts Complaint for Contempt – Serve that Summons!

Many times a case gets dismissed for failure to provide adequate notice to the other party that a complaint has been filed.  This is because the the other party has a right to be given notice of any actions taken against them or that they are named in a proceeding. ...

2021 Update! Still Missing – Maura Murray

March 2021 Update: For those of you following this case, you are probably aware of Tim & Lance's podcast, Missing Maura.  For years, the podcast was its own entity.  Over the years, they began highlighting other cases as well.  To learn about Maura's case, there...

Massachusetts OUI Laws

People often ask me what can happen in the event they (or a family member or friend) are pulled over and suspected of operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol.  Here is some information from the Massachusetts website to help explain the Massachusetts OUI...

I am going to file for divorce myself. I may hire a lawyer later. However, when do I have to move out of the home?

This is a tough question to answer without knowing more about your case. The status of the marital home varies from case to case and is different in New Hampshire than it is in Massachusetts. Is the home being sold? If so, by whom and when? Is your spouse keeping the...

Absent Parents: The Parent Who Used to be Absent

Absent parents is a topic that I see frequently in my practice. Here’s a perfect example: Mom was pregnant but dad wanted nothing to do with her, or the baby, during pregnancy and for a while thereafter. At some point, for whatever reason, the dad becomes interested...

Appeal a Judgment

I recently came across this article "How to Appeal a Judgment without an Attorney."  Being fairly intrigued, I read the article looking for holes that I could use in writing this post.  However, I must admit, it was well written and it was thorough.  It began by...

Massachusetts: The Alimony Reform Act

A recent hot topic in family law is alimony. I’m sure a lot of you have heard of the proposed legislation known as the Alimony Reform Act. This Act aims to define, clarify and guide the Courts, and the litigants, regarding certain aspects of alimony. Amongst other...

How do keep my divorce moving forward?

     This is a common question in my field and it’s one of the most difficult to answer, unfortunately. Divorces can take many paths. The outcome of each case is truly dependant on the parties. So, how can you keep your divorce moving forward...

MA: Can I Hire a Lawyer During COVID-19

Q: Can I hire a lawyer during COVID-19 with the courts being closed? Can they still work on my family law related case? A: Even if the court is closed, having an attorney assist you is so important.  Most importantly, you should not go through this alone.  Having an...

Family Vacation After the Divorce

The reality of a divorce or separation often hits families the hardest over holidays and vacation time.  Family vacations may have been where many memories were created over the years.  Now, after a breakup of the family, it's an emotional time since nobody is quite...

Filing a Protective Order

Filing a protective order (209A) can be a scary time.  Maybe you aren't sure where you will go.  Maybe you have children to consider.  Perhaps your family is not as supportive or available as you need.  There are places and ways to get help so that you are not alone. ...

NH: Can I Hire an Attorney During COVID-19

For my New Hampshire clients, here’s the update:   Currently, the Courts are closed.   You may not go to the court, but the Family Division is conducting some of the court's business behind closed doors.   Here’s what to expect: In an emergency situation,  you will...

If I signed my parental rights away can I get them back?

I often get questions from overwhelmed parents who feel that, for one reason or another, it would be in the best interest of everyone concerned, if they just give up their parental rights (see my other article for more details on this complex subject).  However, many...

Who Gets Our Family Dog in the Divorce?

It's a common scenario.  Boy meets girl and they fall in love.  They buy a home or rent an apartment.  Wanting to share their love, they adopt a dog. Over the next year or so, they get married.  Their dog is their baby.  They share photos of him on social media sites,...

Pin It on Pinterest

Read previous post:
2021 Update! Still Missing – Maura Murray

March 2021 Update: For those of you following this case, you are probably aware of Tim & Lance's podcast, Missing...

Close